Quick answer: Brentford’s strongest campaigns came with Wing Play (10th) and Fluid Counter-Attack (12th), but neither managed that again. Control Possession, Tiki-Taka, Route One and Park the Bus all cost the manager his job by February.
FM27 best tactics: the results
The results here cover Brentford’s 2026/27 Premier League season, using a new save begun on 13 July 2026. The board forecast a 12th-place finish. Quick Pick selected the starting XI, which stayed in place alongside the tactic all season, with no transfers. Wing Play and Fluid Counter-Attack each had another run, making 12 seasons altogether.
Gegenpress, Wing Play and Catenaccio are the three styles marked as a good fit for Brentford’s squad.
| Style | IP formation | OOP formation | Mentality | Finish | W-D-L | Pts | GF-GA | xG | xGA |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Wing Play | 4-2-4 DM Wide | 4-2-2-2 DM Wide | Balanced | 10th | 14-8-16 | 50 | 47-53 | 48.09 | 65.19 |
| Fluid Counter-Attack | 4-3-3 DM Wide | 4-3-3 DM Wide | Cautious | 12th | 14-7-17 | 49 | 37-53 | 38.66 | 58.34 |
| Gegenpress | 4-3-3 DM Wide | 4-3-3 DM Wide | Balanced | 15th | 12-9-17 | 45 | 61-70 | 59.43 | 62.14 |
| Catenaccio | 3-4-3 DM Wide | 3-4-3 DM Wide | Defensive | 16th | 11-7-20 | 40 | 33-54 | 36.18 | 65.97 |
| Vertical Tiki-Taka | 4-3-3 DM Wide | 4-3-3 DM Wide | Balanced | 17th | 8-10-20 | 34 | 48-75 | 43.94 | 71.35 |
| Fluid Counter-Attack (second season) | 4-3-3 DM Wide | 4-3-3 DM Wide | Cautious | 18th, relegated | 9-12-17 | 39 | 40-59 | 41.32 | 68.87 |
| Direct Counter-Attack | 4-2-2-2 DM Wide | 4-2-2-2 DM Wide | Cautious | 19th, relegated | 8-9-21 | 33 | 28-62 | 33.47 | 62.71 |
| Control Possession | 4-3-3 DM Wide | 4-3-3 DM Wide | Positive | Sacked 16 Jan 2027 (19th) | 4-4-14 | 16 | 18-43 | 23.80 | 40.38 |
| Tiki-Taka | 4-3-3 DM Wide | 4-3-3 DM Wide | Positive | Sacked about 9 Jan 2027 (19th) | n/a | n/a | n/a | n/a | n/a |
| Route One | 4-2-4 DM Wide | 4-2-2-2 DM Wide | Balanced | Sacked about 16 Jan 2027 (19th) | n/a | n/a | n/a | n/a | n/a |
| Wing Play (second season) | 4-2-4 DM Wide | 4-2-2-2 DM Wide | Balanced | Sacked about 16 Jan 2027 (19th) | n/a | n/a | n/a | n/a | n/a |
| Park the Bus | 4-2-2-2 DM Wide | 4-2-2-2 DM Wide | Defensive | Sacked about 10 Feb 2027 (20th) | n/a | n/a | n/a | n/a | n/a |
The Control Possession row is the league table on 26 January 2027, just after the sacking. Rows marked n/a are seasons that didn’t reach the end under that tactic. No style finished above 10th.

Join readers who trust AllThings.How
Add us as a preferred source on Google so our practical guides show up first next time you search.
Add to Google Preferences →How each tactical style did
Styles that finished the season
Wing Play took Brentford to 10th in 2026/27, with Dango Ouattara leading the scoring on 14 goals. The team conceded 12 fewer goals than its xGA, while expected points placed it 16th, below its actual finish. In the next season, the unchanged preset and XI had Brentford down in 19th when the manager was sacked in mid-January. The replacement coach had the team 16th on 34 points after 32 games.
Fluid Counter-Attack put Brentford 12th despite just 37 goals, with Yehor Yarmoliuk leading the team on 9 and no player reaching 10. Expected points ranked Brentford 17th. In season two, the team ended up 18th and went down with 39 points; the board dismissed the coach after the campaign.
Gegenpress ended 15th, but no style scored more: it put away 61 goals, with Kevin Schade accounting for 19. Its xG for and against came closest to level among all the styles. Its 50.07 expected points placed it 11th, the best result of the lot. It let in 70 goals; its FA Cup run ended in round 5, and its Carabao Cup run stopped in round 3.

Catenaccio ended 16th on just 33 goals, with Schade top scoring on 11. Expected points had it 20th, and Brentford stayed up by letting in 12 fewer goals than its xGA.
Vertical Tiki-Taka survived in 17th, with Schade again scoring 19, but its 75 goals conceded are the most of any full season.
Direct Counter-Attack ended in 19th and went down, while its expected-points ranking was 20th. The board dismissed the coach after relegation.

Styles that got the manager sacked
Control Possession had Brentford on 16 points after 22 games, with 18 goals scored and 43 conceded, when the board sacked the manager in January. Expected points also placed the team 19th, in line with its results.
Tiki-Taka, the other Positive-mentality possession preset, was also sacked in January at 19th. Brentford finished that season 20th and relegated with 27 points.
Route One lasted until about 16 January 2027 before the sack at 19th, and Brentford went on to finish 20th and relegated with 27 points.
Park the Bus lasted longer than the other dismissed styles, with the manager staying until about 10 February 2027. Brentford were bottom by then, and finished 20th with 29 points and relegation.
What the results show
- Across full seasons, every style’s xGA was higher than its xG, with xGA totals ranging from 58 to 71.
- Wing Play finished 10th and Fluid Counter-Attack 12th, the only styles to match the board’s 12th-place forecast. Each reached that mark once.
- Wing Play’s unchanged setup and lineup first brought Brentford 10th, then led to a mid-season sacking the next time around. One season alone can’t show which style is best.
- Gegenpress, Wing Play and Catenaccio, the three styles with the thumbs-up for Brentford’s squad, all kept the job through their first full season.
- All four first-season sackings came from styles without the thumbs-up.
- The two Positive-mentality possession presets, Control Possession and Tiki-Taka, both saw the manager sacked in January.
- Gegenpress stood well clear for chances created, with 59.43 xG, and led the styles on expected points as well.
Which FM27 tactic to use
With a mid-table squad, start from a style that shows the thumbs-up for your players. From these seasons, Wing Play and Gegenpress are the best-backed picks, with Fluid Counter-Attack not far behind. With a squad like Brentford’s, stay away from Control Possession, Tiki-Taka, Park the Bus and Route One unless you plan to change them. To build a squad for your chosen style, see the best FM27 wonderkids and the best free agents, or add community tactics from the FM27 Steam Workshop.
A preset that’s left alone all season gives away too many chances, so expect to work on the defensive side. If you’re not sure where those settings live, start with how tactics work in FM27.
FAQ
What is the best FM27 formation?
Wing Play’s 4-2-4 DM Wide in possession, with 4-2-2-2 DM Wide out of possession, got the best finish. Gegenpress’s 4-3-3 DM Wide scored the most goals.






