Quick answer: Position a loose D20 above the shop’s purple tray at the front counter, then press Q to release it. Roll again until you get a 20 and unlock “You’re a natural!”
You unlock the You’re a natural! achievement when the die lands on 20 in the shop’s rolling tray. You don’t need a special die, and you don’t need a menu or prompt. You just drop the die until the number comes up.
Where the rolling tray is
The Dice Hoarder shop has one rolling tray. It’s a wooden tray lined with purple felt, and it sits on the front counter beside an inkwell with a black quill and a closed book. The black shop cat often sits on the counter right next to it.

You can use any D20. For instance, take the plain Light Blue Plastic D20 from the shop floor using the left mouse button. Its Held Die card lists “D20”, “Material: Plastic” and “Color: Light Blue”. The die’s set makes no difference.

Join readers who trust AllThings.How
Add us as a preferred source on Google so our practical guides show up first next time you search.
Add to Google Preferences →How to roll a die in the tray
At the counter, aim down at the tray with the die suspended above the felt. The game provides no prompt or on-screen instruction for rolling there, so position the D20 yourself.
Use Q (Drop) to release the die. It drops into the tray, tumbles around, then settles on the felt.

After the die settles, its result briefly appears floating above it. A low result might display as a blue “2”, for example.

Keep rolling until it shows 20
Use the left mouse button to retrieve the die, position it above the felt again, and press Q. Keep repeating these steps until 20 appears as the floating result. It may take many attempts.
You can’t miss a natural 20 when it happens. The game shows “20” above the die, and sparkling stars appear around the tray.

The You’re a natural! achievement
The achievement unlocks on that same roll. A notification appears in the bottom right reading “You’re a natural!” with the line “Roll a natural 20 in a rolling tray” underneath.

The die remains in the tray after the roll.






