The Pizzeria is Detective Duck’s weekly case, filed in-game as Case #: 0088 – Nonna’s Secret Sauce. The night before the town’s pizza contest, someone opened the locked walk-in fridge at Pizzeria Bella at 10:31 PM and took the sauce. The puzzles are reshuffled every time you load in, and so is the culprit. A walkthrough that gives you one fixed answer will fail you about as often as it helps.
Quick answer: Open the kitchen, solve its lock, collect all seven clues, then inspect the fingerprint on the walk-in fridge scanner. Vote for whoever it names. In tested runs that was Lucy (Cashier) or Sofia (Customer).
Pizzeria case suspects and what you are proving
The restaurant greets you as Andrea’s Pizza, but the case file calls it Pizzeria Bella. You have four suspects. Only one of them left a print on the fridge scanner in any given round.
| Suspect | Role | Culprit in tested runs |
|---|---|---|
| Sofia | Customer | Yes (one run) |
| Mr. Romano | Manager | No |
| Lucy | Cashier | Yes (two runs) |
| Jake | Dishwasher | No |
Sofia’s suspect card lists her as 21 years old. It also notes that she comes in every single day and always orders extra sauce. That is flavor text. The fingerprint is the only thing that settles the vote, so do not convict anyone off a profile or off last week’s answer.
Join readers who trust AllThings.How
Add us as a preferred source on Google so our practical guides show up first next time you search.
Add to Google Preferences →Pizzeria puzzle variants: Which one you got
Every round uses the same building and the same goal. The route into the kitchen and its locked box changes, though. Look around the dining room first. A glowing pattern on the hanging Italian flag means you have the neonpad route. Rotten tomatoes lying around mean you have the blender route.
| Variant | Dining room | Kitchen |
|---|---|---|
| Neonpad route | Flag pattern opens a box | Lockbox, then diary code |
| Blender route | Tomato acid melts a box | Tomato acid, then neonpad |
Both routes share the same lockpicking mini-game at the kitchen door. You have to land the moving bar inside the highlighted zone three times in a row. Press the on-screen HIT button or click the mouse when the slider is over the target. The game rates each hit as GOOD or CLOSE.
Neonpad route: Flag pattern, lockpicks, and the diary code




Tested rounds have used 3831 and 7068. The diary is randomized along with everything else, so always enter the number your own copy shows.

Blender route: Making acidic juice from rotten tomatoes
In this version, metal lockboxes take the place of the flag and the diary. You melt them with juice made from tomatoes. Each room needs its own batch of four.
Add Juice prompt. The lock melts, and the Lockpick inside is yours.All seven Pizzeria evidence clue locations
Clearing the puzzles is not enough. If you try to end the investigation early, the phone shows “YOU CAN’T END THE INVESTIGATION YET.” It tells you to discover all room suspect clues first. Equip the Magnifying Glass or UV Light and hold it near a sparkling clue. Then press the inspect prompt that appears.
| Clue | Location | Tool |
|---|---|---|
| Text On Wall | Near the kitchen doorway | UV Light |
| Hair On Floor | Kitchen floor | Magnifying Glass |
| Hair Near Sink | Kitchen counter | Magnifying Glass |
| Fingerprint Part | Kitchen table or floor | Magnifying Glass |
| Fingerprint Part | Kitchen/living area floor | Magnifying Glass |
| Hair Near Cash Register | Counter by the register | Magnifying Glass |
| Cloth Piece Near Cash Register | Counter corner | Magnifying Glass |
Each find pops a “Revealed:” notice with the clue’s name. The UV text on the wall complains that someone called “THREE times today” asking for the fridge code. The name in that note changes between rounds, and both Marco and Gino have shown up. Neither one is on the suspect list.

Once the seventh clue is logged, the game says you can now end the investigation. Equip the phone to do that.
Fridge fingerprint and voting the Pizzeria culprit
Inspect the fingerprint reader beside the walk-in fridge door. It names whoever opened the fridge, with a line like “This is the fingerprint of Lucy (Cashier)!” or “This is the fingerprint of Sofia (Customer)!” That name is the answer for your round.
END INVESTIGATION. This takes you to the interrogation room, and RESUME INVESTIGATION will bring you back if you need it.You know you solved it when “Well done, Detective. You caught the right suspect.” appears. The culprit goes into a cell, and then the Supreme Court of Ducks card loads. It lists the charge as theft of a secret recipe. The sentence is to return the sauce, apologize to Nonna, and wash every dish at the Pizzeria for a month. From there you can pick REPLAY to see a new puzzle mix, or RETURN TO LOBBY. If you are not in the game yet, the case is in the free Detective Duck experience on Roblox.





