Ocha needs something personal from Andrei before she can cast her hex, and the quest marker in Svartrau City drops you outside a butcher’s shop that doubles as the crime boss’s hideout. Three objects sit in that room, and only one of them carries enough meaning to Andrei for the hex to bite.
Quick answer: Take Andrei’s Ring, not the pendant or the cleaver, then return to Ocha and pick the line “The ring. Must be important.” The safest way in is to wait for nighttime and climb the balcony.
Why the ring is the correct memento
A hex needs an object tied to the target. Andrei tells you the answer himself during the trade conversation, when he recalls his father hitting him hard enough that the ring on his hand nearly split his skull open. That scar, and the ring he later took for himself, is the memory the hex latches onto.
| Item | Result |
|---|---|
| Andrei’s Ring | Correct. The hex succeeds and Andrei starts slamming his own head into the wall. |
| Andrei’s Pendant | Wrong. It belongs to Katja, not Andrei, so the hex fails. |
| The cleaver | Wrong. It carries no personal weight for him. |
Note: if you hand Ocha the wrong memento, Nora is in real danger later. You then have to shout “Step away from her!” instead of staying hidden, or she can die.
Join readers who trust AllThings.How
Add us as a preferred source on Google so our practical guides show up first next time you search.
Add to Google Preferences →Two ways into Andrei’s hideout
The hideout sits behind Dragan the Butcher’s shop. You can either climb in from above after dark or buy an audience by pretending to be a silver seller. Both routes end with the same three objects on the desk, but they carry very different consequences.
| Route | What you need | Trade-off |
|---|---|---|
| Balcony at night | Nighttime plus your vampiric climbing power | Skips every conversation and every fight risk. Nora is never taken hostage. |
| Butcher’s door | 50 denarii for the beggar (or 400 for Katja) and a silver item in your inventory | Andrei’s goons take Nora hostage afterwards, and hostile dialogue starts a fight. |
Do not try the balcony during the day. Climbing in while the NPCs inside are still on their daytime routine breaks their scripting, and the quest can no longer progress.
Balcony route: Take the ring at night




Butcher’s door route: Safe dialogue answers
| Moment | Safe reply | Starts a fight |
|---|---|---|
| Showing the butcher your silver | “Here it is.” / “Alright, here.” | “Just move.” |
| The debtor losing a finger | [stay silent] | “I said let him go.” |
| Handing Andrei the silver | “Here’s what I’ve got.” | “I’m here to talk about Ocha.” |
| “Nervous, are we?” | “I don’t trust you, is all.” or “Who wouldn’t be? What we’re doing here is illegal.” | “You don’t impress me.” |
| The cleaver threat | “You know how to handle it, that’s for sure.” | “Your threats bore me.” |
Tip: killing Andrei’s men locks the The Outcast trophy, and killing Andrei himself puts Ocha at odds with you because it wrecks her plan.
How to confirm the memento worked
The first confirmation is the Journal. Once the ring is in your inventory, “Acquire Andrei’s memento” clears and “Return to Ocha” appears as the new objective, with “Look for more of Andrei’s mementos” listed as optional.

Returning to Ocha costs two time segments. If you used the butcher’s door, she tells you that Andrei’s men have grabbed Nora and dragged her into the hideout you just left. Answer with “We should stick to the plan” rather than letting Ocha charge in.
Go back outside, use Focus Mode, and either open the pig cage by the fence or pay Katja 50 denarii to pull the guard away. Then look through the ground-floor window. With the ring as the memento, the hex lands and Andrei starts driving his head into the wall, which is the visual proof you picked correctly.
Reasons the memento step fails
Only a handful of things actually break this objective, and all of them are avoidable.
- Climbing to the balcony during daylight, which breaks the NPC scripting inside and stalls the quest.
- Approaching the butcher without a silver item, since the “I have some silver to sell” option needs one in your inventory.
- Choosing an aggressive line with Dragan or Andrei, which turns the meeting into combat before you ever reach the desk.
- Giving Ocha the pendant or the cleaver, which makes the hex fizzle and puts Nora at risk.
If you are after a clean run with no bodies and no hostage sequence, the night climb is the shortest path. Grab the ring off the desk, sweep the chest for the Ring of Quick Strikes and the Recipe for Powder of Sharp Mind while you are there, and walk back out with everything Ocha needs.






