The last optional challenge in Chapter 5, Into The Shadows, asks Michael to wreck a police car before slipping out of Haddonfield. The task reads as if one cruiser is enough, but the challenge is more particular than its wording suggests, and it can quietly refuse to register if you reset the level. Here is exactly what makes it complete.
Quick answer: Smash both police cars with melee attacks (about six hits with the knife) until each car’s hood pops, its lights go dark, and the engine smokes, then reach an escape route without getting caught. Do this in a single run without restarting the chapter, or the challenge may not count.

What to do before you wreck a car
Michael starts this chapter weakened after being shot, so he cannot use Shape Jump right away. Two police cars sit around the suburb, and one of them patrols while searching for your position. Before you touch either car, settle a couple of things first, because destroying a cruiser changes how the map behaves.
Wrecking a car calls more officers to the scene. If you still want the challenge to fully stalk a police officer inside the Wallace house, finish that one first. Once a car is destroyed, the cops who were inside the house may relocate, which removes your chance to complete that stalk.

It also helps to get Shape Jump back before the streets fill with police. Fill Michael’s Tier 2 Bloodthirst meter completely to unlock the ability again, which gives you a way to slip out without being swarmed after the alarm goes up.

How to destroy a police car

Why the challenge may not complete
Two specific problems stop this challenge from ticking off, and both are easy to trip over.
| Problem | Fix |
|---|---|
| Only one cruiser destroyed | Wreck both police cars in the same run before escaping. |
| Level was restarted mid-attempt | Complete the chapter from the start without restarting. Restarting can prevent the challenge from triggering. |
If you do need to restart, do not use a mid-level reset. Return all the way to the main menu and reselect the chapter. This drops you back at the same spot and still leaves the challenge available to complete.
Confirming the challenge is done
Destroying the cars does not finish the challenge on its own. You still need to leave Haddonfield. Head for one of the escape routes and reach it before the police catch you. The Sewer Escape is available in this chapter, and an alternate route over the train tracks can be found by heading left instead of north.

With both cruisers wrecked and an exit reached, the challenge mark shows as complete when the chapter ends. If you are avoiding Dr. Loomis for the separate detection challenge, keep clear of the large red marker on the map while you make your way to the exit.

The main thing to remember is to treat this as a two-car job handled in one uninterrupted run. Wreck both cruisers, keep the option to reach the sewer or the tracks open, and only leave once the second car is smoking.






