The Crazy Cat Lady in Fisch hands out three-part quests, and each one hides the fish you need behind a short riddle. Talk to her and you get a random clue that describes a creature by its look, its mutation, or where it lives. The trick is turning that poetic hint into the exact catch she wants.
Quick answer: Read the riddle, match it to the fish in the tables below, catch that fish in the listed location, then hand it to the Crazy Cat Lady to complete that part of the quest.
How the Crazy Cat Lady quests work
The quest chain runs across three parts. Each time you speak to her, she gives you one riddle at random and asks for a specific fish in return. Some riddles point to a base fish, while others describe a special mutation of that fish, such as a Shiny, Frozen, or Celestial variant. You have to bring the exact match, so knowing which mutation the clue hints at matters as much as the base creature.
You can play Fisch and start the quests through the Fisch game page on Roblox.
First part riddle answers
| Riddle clue | Fish to catch | Where to catch it |
|---|---|---|
| “In glassbound night where starlight weaves, a galaxy swims beneath black seas.” | Shiny Celestial Koi | Atlantis |
| “Intricate patterns light the abyss below, reflections of art, bathed in a cerulean glow.” | Atlantean Mosaic Swimmer | Atlantis |
| “Within Poseidon’s storm, the void grows electric, weaving death’s beauty through the darkest depths.” | Electric Void Angler | The Atlantean Storm |
| “Winged through sunlight, halos crown its fleeting flight, an angel skimming waves, dancing with the light.” | Shiny Flying Fish | The Ocean |
| “An emperor among coral, it reigns with abyssal might, teeth and fins of terror, sovereign of the light.” | Abyssal Coral Emperor | The Grand Reef |
Second part riddle answers
| Riddle clue | Fish to catch | Where to catch it |
|---|---|---|
| “In twilight’s hush, their ashen glow unveils, hidden paths in ruins where mystery prevails.” | Ashen Fortune Twilight Glowfish | Atlantis |
| “With a carrot in its beak, it moves with grace, rainbow scales shimmering in this quiet place.” | Carrot Prismatic Parrotfish | The Calm Zone |
| “In the shadowed altar, a frozen shadow glides, gentle in darkness, swift when angered tides.” | Frozen Umbral Shark | Keepers Altar |
| “In pastel hues where soft light gleams, whiskers drift through iridescent dreams.” | Shiny Mosaic Opalescent Catfish | Crystal Cove |
| “In the quiet deep, a soft lunar glow plays, dancing on gills that map the night’s hidden maze.” | Lunar Midnight Axolotl | The Desolate Deep |
Third part riddle answers
| Riddle clue | Fish to catch | Where to catch it |
|---|---|---|
| “Frost-wrought blaze beneath mirrored skies, colors dissolve where skrunkly stillness flies.” | Skrunkly Aurora Trout | The Cyrogenic Canal |
| “Marks like constellations adorn its regal crest, calming the waters where the deep rests best.” | Celestial Deep Crownfish | Atlantis |
| “In the dark depths, its glowing eyes ignite, a colossal shadow slipping through the secret night.” | Ancient Depth Serpent | The Depths of Vertigo during the Absolute Darkness event |
| “Hexed and serpent-like, it drifts below, a silent herald where the ocean currents flow.” | Hexed Oarfish | The Ocean |
| “A fleeting anomaly hops through the deep, leaping in rhythm where the quiet waters sleep.” | Anomalous Rabbitfish | The Ocean |
How to get the right mutations
Several riddles ask for a mutated version of a base fish, so the location alone is not enough. You need the correct variant on the line before it counts. Here is where the required mutations come from.
| Mutation | How to get it |
|---|---|
| Shiny | Shiny Surge, appraisal, Blessed Enchantment, Glittered Enchantment, Destiny Rod, Axe of Rhoads, Polaris Serenade, or Crysalis Rod |
| Atlantean | Trident Rod |
| Electric | Appraisal, naturally, or Storming Enchant |
| Abyssal | Naturally in The Depths, appraisal, Abyssal Enchantment, Rod of The Depths, or Abyssal Specter Rod |
| Ashen Fortune | Volcanic and Magma Rod |
| Carrot | Carrot Rod and Carrot Pool |
| Frozen | Appraisal, Snowstorm, naturally, Arctic, or Summit Rod |
| Mosaic | Naturally or appraisal |
| Lunar | Astral and Event Horizon Rod, Moonlit Mirage, or appraisal |
| Skrunkly | Nico’s Yarncaster Rod |
| Celestial | Celestial Rod and Heavenly Sparkles event |
| Hexed | Naturally, appraisal, or No-Life Rod |
| Anomalous | Anomalous Enchantment |
Turning in the fish and confirming the quest
Once you have the exact fish and, where needed, the exact mutation, return to the Crazy Cat Lady and give her the catch. Handing over the correct creature advances that part of the quest, and working through all three parts is how you earn the rewards tied to the chain, including the Skrunkly-granting Nico’s Yarncaster Rod.
If a turn-in does not register, the most common reason is a mismatch on the mutation. A base Celestial Koi will not satisfy a riddle that asks for the Shiny Celestial Koi, so double-check the variant against the tables above before you dive back out for another catch.
