Right-clicking on one monitor and seeing the context menu pop up on another can slow down workflow and cause confusion, especially when using multiple displays with Windows 11. This issue often results from display configuration mismatches, outdated graphics drivers, or system glitches related to how Windows handles multi-monitor setups.

Adjust Display Settings to Match Physical Monitor Arrangement

Step 1: Open the Windows Settings app by pressing Windows + I. Click on System and then select Display from the sidebar. This section allows you to configure your monitors’ arrangement.

Step 2: Under the “Rearrange your displays” section, drag the monitor icons to match the physical layout of your monitors on your desk. For example, if Monitor 2 is physically to the left of Monitor 1, ensure Monitor 2 is also shown to the left in this diagram. This alignment helps Windows accurately track where to display context menus and other pop-ups.

Step 3: Click Apply to save the changes. Test the right-click menu on each screen to confirm that it now appears on the correct monitor.

Update Graphics Drivers

Step 1: Outdated or corrupted graphics drivers can cause display inconsistencies. To update, right-click the Start button and select Device Manager.

Step 2: Expand the Display adapters section. Right-click your graphics card and choose Update driver.

Step 3: Select Search automatically for drivers. If an update is found, install it and restart your computer. This can resolve bugs that impact how Windows manages context menus across multiple screens.

Change Main Display Assignment

Step 1: In some cases, Windows may prioritize the primary monitor for context menus, even if you right-click on a secondary screen. To change the main display, return to Settings > System > Display.

Step 2: Click on the monitor you want to set as your main display. Scroll down and check the box labeled Make this my main display. This change guides Windows to anchor context menus and taskbars to your preferred monitor.

Step 3: Click Apply and test the right-click menu behavior.

Restart Windows Explorer

Step 1: If the problem persists, restarting Windows Explorer can clear temporary glitches. Press Ctrl + Shift + Esc to open Task Manager.

Step 2: Scroll down to find Windows Explorer in the list. Right-click it and choose Restart. The taskbar and desktop will briefly disappear and reload.

Step 3: After Explorer restarts, check if the right-click context menu appears on the correct screen.

Check for Windows Updates

Step 1: Display bugs are sometimes fixed in Windows updates. Open Settings and navigate to Windows Update.

Step 2: Click Check for updates. If updates are available, install them and restart your PC. This can resolve underlying system issues affecting multi-monitor behavior.

With these steps, right-click context menus should reliably appear on the intended monitor in Windows 11. Keeping display drivers and system updates current helps prevent similar issues in the future.