Gaming Guide

The Sinking City 2: Which Talent to Unlock First

How the Talent Table works and the smartest first pick for each combat style in Arkham.

How the Talent Table works and the smartest first pick for each combat style in Arkham.

Talents in The Sinking City 2 are small combat buffs you buy at the Talent Table inside safe rooms, and the first one you pick should match whatever is currently draining your health, ammo, or time in a fight. There is no single strongest option. Calvin can only equip a handful at once, so a focused choice beats a random powerful effect every time.

Quick answer: Spend your first Dream Essence on a Basic talent that fixes your biggest problem right now. Take Carapace of the Damned if humanoids keep hurting you early, Potent Tincture on higher difficulties where survival is tight, or Profane Reload if reloading leaves you exposed. Buy four Basic talents to open the Intermediate tier.

Image credit: Frogwares

When you unlock Talents and how the Talent Table works

The first Talent Table appears in part three of the story, after the man with worms in his eyes sends you toward a nearby hotel. Once you push through the church and graveyard and open the first locked door, the safe room inside gives you access to the Talent Table. Every safe room from that point on lets you use it.

Talents are paid for with Dream Essence, a collectible you earn by clearing major story beats and solving the mysteries and puzzles you connect in the Investigation Space. There is a limited amount per run, so check the table often and spend deliberately.

Each Talent slots into your Mask. You can equip up to four at a time, one round talent plus three diamond-shaped ones, and the shape decides where it can go. Because of that shape limit, you cannot stack every effect you want, and you should treat your loadout as a set built for the section ahead rather than a permanent upgrade. You can swap Talents freely at any Talent Table.

Image credit: Frogwares / Jason’s Video Games Source

Talent tiers and unlock order

Talents are grouped into tiers, and you climb them by buying enough from the tier below. Better effects sit higher up, with the strongest saved for a special Eldritch Rewards tier that opens as you complete in-game goals.

TierHow to unlock it
BasicAvailable as soon as you reach the first Talent Table
IntermediateBuy four Basic talents
AdvancedBuy four Intermediate talents
Eldritch RewardsOpens by completing specific in-game goals

This structure is the real reason your first purchases matter. Even if a low-tier talent is modest on its own, buying four of them is the gate to the more meaningful Intermediate options, so progressing quickly is worth more early than holding out for something perfect.


Best first Talent for each playstyle

Pick your opening talent by the action you perform most reliably. If you rarely trigger an effect, it is a wasted slot no matter how strong it reads.

If you play like thisStart with
Struggling to survive early fightsCarapace of the Damned
On a higher difficulty, hoarding healsPotent Tincture
Prefer ranged combat and craft ammoAlchemical Abundance
Rotate between multiple weaponsGunslinger’s Trance and Instruments of Death
Rely on one gun and reload oftenProfane Reload
Fight up close and finish kills with meleeButcher’s Zeal and Inner Beast
Fight with the flashlight offSilent Hunter
Aim for weak pointsWandering Bullet

Because combat leans on scarce bullets and healing items, especially early on, a defensive or resource pick usually pays off before an offensive one. Fleeing is often smarter than fighting, so anything that keeps Calvin alive between encounters stretches your supplies further.

Image credit: Frogwares

Every Talent and who it suits

Basic Talents

TalentEffect and best fit
Carapace of the DamnedTake a little less harm from humanoids. Good for finding your footing early.
Gunslinger’s TranceSwap weapons a little faster. For players juggling several guns.
Instruments of DeathDeal a little more harm for a few seconds after swapping weapons.
Potent TinctureTake less harm for every healing item carried, up to five. Strong on higher difficulties.
Profane ReloadReload noticeably faster. For gun-focused players who want less downtime.
Silent HunterStrike harder with your flashlight off. For fighting in the dark.

Intermediate Talents

TalentEffect and best fit
Alchemical AbundanceGain noticeably more ammunition when crafting. For ranged players.
Butcher’s ZealDeal huge melee damage for a few seconds after a kill.
ChitinboundTake a little less harm from monsters and aberrations.
Feral SurgeDeal more harm to creatures at close range.
Strange EvasionTake less harm for a few seconds after dodging. For tactical dodgers.
Unhallowed SalveRecover noticeably more from healing items.

Advanced Talents

TalentEffect and best fit
Crimson ThresholdDeal more harm when low on health. For aggressive, high-risk play.
Deathless VigorWithstand noticeably more punishment. General survivability.
Inner BeastDeal much more melee damage with an empty magazine.
Opening GambitThe first bullet fired hits harder. For confident aim.
Vengeful SpiritIf slain, quickly kill your killer to escape death. For higher difficulties.
Wandering BulletDeal more harm to weak points with unfocused shots.

Higher tiers also add specialist options like Reticle Ritual and Ruptured Core for weak-point shooters, plus Pact of the Reaper and Vessel of Destruction for high-risk builds that turn vulnerability into extra offense. These reward very specific habits, so they belong later once your core loadout is settled.

Image credit: Frogwares

How to confirm a Talent is active and avoid wasting Essence

A purchased Talent appears in your Mask loadout at the Talent Table, and only equipped Talents apply their effect in combat. If a bonus never seems to fire, check that its trigger matches how you actually play. Instruments of Death and Gunslinger’s Trance do nothing if you stick to one gun, Silent Hunter helps only with your flashlight off, and Reticle Ritual is dead weight if pressure keeps forcing rushed shots.

Dream Essence is limited, so treat each buy as a step toward the next tier as much as an immediate boost. Before leaving a safe room, swap out any Talent whose trigger will not come up in the stretch ahead and slot in something that will. If you plan to eventually learn every Talent for the What Dreams Are Made Of trophy, that goal spans multiple playthroughs, so early spending on the picks above costs you nothing in the long run.