Missing Officer sends you past the dimensional rift into Diamond Shores, a foggy pirate settlement built from wooden scaffolding and half-sunken ruins. The quest ends when you find Edward behind bars. The follow-up, Rescue Plan, asks you to find the key that opens his cell, and that key sits in the water right outside it.
Quick answer: Edward is in a wooden cage on the far side of Diamond Shores’ flooded cavern. Talk to him, then dive into the pool in front of the cell to grab the Prison Key.
Where to find Edward in Diamond Shores
Once you cross the rift, the game warns that fast travel doesn’t work beyond the boundary. You have to cover Diamond Shores on foot and in the water. The quest tracker reads “Find Edward (0/1).” Follow the blue objective marker on your compass as it pulls you through the settlement toward the cavern at the back of the area.
The docks and shacks are full of Pirates of Madness. You’ll meet Archers, Warriors, Illusionists, and Juggernauts, plus a regular Pirate or two. Several fights take place on narrow walkways over the water, so you can drop into the sea and climb back up wherever the boards run out.

There’s a Brewing Furnace near the entrance where you can craft Lifeflow Potions before you take on the pirate camps.
After Garret and the Awakening Nui Statue, cross the wooden deck. Climb one of the ladders to reach the cliffside catwalks, then follow the elevated walkways until you can drop to the ground near the cavern.

The last stretch is a swim. Cross the flooded cavern basin toward the torchlit wooden structure on the far side, where Edward and another prisoner, Kevin, are locked in.

Join readers who trust AllThings.How
Add us as a preferred source on Google so our practical guides show up first next time you search.
Add to Google Preferences →Prison Key location and how to unlock Edward’s cell
Talking to Edward through the bars completes Missing Officer and immediately starts Rescue Plan. The new objective explains that the key is missing and tells you to use Kevin’s hint to search the area. You don’t have to search far.


You’ll know it worked when the gate swings open and the cutscene starts. Rescue Plan’s objective then clears from the tracker. On a character at this point in the story, the reward XP can also trigger a level-up to Lv. 8.
Missing Officer and Rescue Plan rewards
| Quest | Completes when | EXP | Currency |
|---|---|---|---|
| Missing Officer | You talk to Edward at the cell | 2,500 | 550 |
| Rescue Plan | You unlock the cell gate | 4,500 | 1,500 |
Both quests finish at the same spot, only a few seconds apart. Together they’re worth 7,000 EXP and 2,050 Currency. Most of the time goes into getting through Diamond Shores. Once you reach the cage, the key is only one dive away.






