Gaming How-To

How to Beat the Butcher in Phantom Blade Zero (Crimson Forest)

Where the hook-and-cleaver elite stands, which swings to parry or dodge, and what the kill pays in Remnant Dust.

Where the hook-and-cleaver elite stands, which swings to parry or dodge, and what the kill pays in Remnant Dust.

The Butcher raising his cleaver over Soul on a Crimson Forest path in Phantom Blade Zero

Quick answer: Stay at sword range so his hook can’t drag you in, parry his blue-flash swings, dodge the red-flash cleaver sweep, and hit back only in short bursts right after a parry.

The Butcher is a large elite enemy in Phantom Blade Zero’s Crimson Forest: a fat, masked brute with a meat hook and a cleaver who punishes both greedy attacks and cautious distance. The fight shown here took about 100 seconds.


Where to find the Butcher

The first Butcher stands on the trail southwest of the Outlaw Trap bell, the Crimson Forest’s second bell after the Crane Bell. Follow that trail away from the Outlaw Trap bell and it leads straight to him.

He isn’t a boss. No boss bar appears along the bottom of the screen; instead, a short health bar sits over his head. The first Butcher has 7,580 health.

The Butcher with his meat hook raised and cleaver in hand facing Soul in the Crimson Forest

A second Butcher is stationed in the lower-level butcher’s yard beneath the Outlaw Trap bell, with hounds roaming around it. In the yard the hounds are the first threat: charging straight at that Butcher lets three hounds bring you down before you reach him, so clear the hounds first. Every other enemy type is in the full enemy list.


How to reach the second Butcher’s yard

Start in the bandit camp in the Crimson Forest. It is the camp with huts and a chest that holds a Sha-Chi Amber Shard. Open the wooden gate on the camp’s edge with E. Then follow the path past it south until a set of stairs takes you down into a cave area.
E prompt at the bandit camp gate in the Crimson Forest in Phantom Blade Zero
At the stairway’s base, a timber structure stands beside the rock face, with a ladder fixed to it. Leave the ladder alone: it leads only to a small storage loft packed with crates. The loft’s other exit is a chained cage gate with no prompt. A deep pit filled with Sick Dogs lies below the ladder and to its west.
Ladder with its Space prompt in the cave area below the bandit camp in Phantom Blade Zero
From the ladder’s foot, walk north along the ledge. Avoid going west or south-west: the pit edge is directly ahead in either direction, and a misstep sends you down among the hounds. The fall may kill you outright; if it doesn’t, you could end up facing two Sick Dogs at once.
Ledge by the ladder foot with the drop into the hound pit and a walkway beyond in Phantom Blade Zero
A little farther along the ledge, a broad wooden plank walkway begins on your left and spans the pit to the west. Partway across, the planks curve south-west. Take the bend instead of continuing straight. The walkway reaches the Butcher’s yard at the same elevation, where a lantern and hanging bodies are ahead and the Butcher stands in the yard.
Soul on the wooden plank walkway over the hound pit in the Crimson Forest in Phantom Blade Zero

A Sick Dog patrols the yard near the walkway’s end and joins a Butcher fight you start from that spot. On PATHBREAKER, each bite takes over a tenth of your health bar. Clear all hounds near the yard before taking on the Butcher at full health, and stay clear of the pit edge.

The Butcher standing by a lantern at the end of the plank walkway in his Crimson Forest yard

Beating the second Butcher

In the Crimson Forest, the second Butcher occupies a yard beyond the plank walkway that crosses the hound pit. He takes longer to defeat than the first, though facing him without anyone else keeps the battle manageable.

Clear the Sick Dogs around the yard before you engage the Butcher. Once they are dead, nothing else joins the fight, so it stays one on one.
Move toward the yard’s center, among the leaves soaked with blood. The Butcher will face you there, hook and cleaver ready.
Soul squaring up to the second Butcher in his Crimson Forest yard in Phantom Blade Zero
His attacks arrive in rapid strings, so deflect them as you guard. A deflection timed correctly sends sparks flying and halts the blow.
Sparks as Soul deflects the second Butcher's swing in Phantom Blade Zero
His jump carries him toward you inside a green cloud of poisonous miasma. Move clear of where he lands rather than trying to trade blows beneath him.
The second Butcher leaping in a green haze of miasma in Phantom Blade Zero
A combo’s end leaves him hunched over. Close in for a brief series of attacks, retreat before he begins another combo, and do it again.
Soul punishing the second Butcher after a combo in Phantom Blade Zero

On WAYFARER, the encounter took roughly 145 seconds, and one heal was used. He falls beside the yard’s stone wall and walkway, leaving about 360 Remnant Dust. Immediately after the kill, the counter shows 52,471.

The second Butcher down by the yard wall with the Remnant Dust counter at 52,471 in Phantom Blade Zero

Faster route back and the talisman fragment in the yard

After applying the Crimson Forest Tunnel Crank to the lift post positioned north of the Outlaw Trap bell, enter the tunnel beneath it. A ladder there descends into this yard, so you can avoid the pit edge.

Before departing, inspect the yard’s western corner. Preservation Talisman Fragment II rests beside a wall built from stacked stones and a suspended brazier.


The Butcher at the crank camp (west of Outlaw Trap)

In Crimson Forest, a small campsite west of the Outlaw Trap bell is occupied by a Butcher and two Sick Dogs. The Crimson Forest Tunnel Crank sits beside the Butcher’s chopping table. The same guard, dodge, and punish strategy used against other Butchers works here too.

Begin at the Outlaw Trap bell and take the westbound path at the bell’s elevation. Along the way, pass a stone lantern beside a patch of glowing blue flowers. A bandit rides patrol nearby; keep going past the area.
Keep going west until you reach a body by a large rock. The body carries the “Words in Blood” lore note.
Turn left and take the stream path down to the camp. The full route is in the Crimson Forest Tunnel Crank walkthrough.

The chopping tables, wooden cages, red candles, and heaps of bodies mark the camp. As soon as you arrive, the Butcher rushes you with his hook and cleaver. The two Sick Dogs are positioned at the crank’s location. Their bites cost a large amount of health, so keep them ahead of you and prevent them from getting behind you while battling the Butcher.

The Butcher charging with his cleaver at the camp west of Outlaw Trap in Phantom Blade Zero

Guard his combos and dodge the big swings. When he finishes a combo, punish him with a short string, then go back to defending.

Soul facing the Butcher beside a wooden cage at the crank camp in Phantom Blade Zero

Keep up the pressure as his health bar drains. On WAYFARER, he goes down in about 88 seconds with one heal used.

The Butcher with his health bar nearly empty at the crank camp in Phantom Blade Zero

The Butcher and the dogs together give about 590 Remnant Dust. The Remnant Dust counter in the top right goes up when they die, and it read 50,023 right after the kill.

Remnant Dust counter at 50,023 after the Butcher falls at the crank camp in Phantom Blade Zero

After clearing the camp, collect the Crimson Forest Tunnel Crank from the ground beside the Butcher’s chopping table.


The Butcher on the plank road above Red Serpent House

In Crimson Forest, the road past the Forest Outpost’s low-road double gate climbs to a long fenced plank road and a plateau. A Butcher and a pack of three dogs hold both. Clearing them opens up a Remnant Dust heap and a ladder down to a chest with three Phantom Edge materials.

Start at the Red Serpent House bell, a wooden cross lit red on the road beyond the low-road double gate opened with the Forest Outpost Courtyard Key. The bells guide lists it alongside the other bells.
Walk the dirt road away from the bell until you reach a small wooden cart bridge. Cross it and take the stone path uphill.
The stone trail gives way to a fenced plank walkway lined with clay jars, which rises to a plateau. The Butcher and his three dogs patrol the walkway’s upper end and the plateau.
Fenced plank road above Red Serpent House where the Butcher and his dogs wait in Phantom Blade Zero

They won’t stay put: the Butcher and dogs may charge down the plank road as a group. If all four reach you, bites from the dogs at your sides and rear deal more of the damage than the Butcher does. On PATHBREAKER, that combination is very punishing.

Separate the dogs and deal with them one at a time. A lone dog went down in about 18 seconds. Keep going until every dog is gone, then face the Butcher alone. He fights like the other Butchers above: block his combos, evade the heavy swings, and strike back after each combo ends. On WAYFARER, defeating him takes about 132 seconds and uses one heal.

Soul on the plank road above Red Serpent House after the Butcher fight in Phantom Blade Zero

After the fight, you’ll find a plateau at the plank road’s upper end, with stone stairs and a lantern. By the clay jars near the edge, a plank ledge marks the ladder’s top; it descends to the cliff scaffold chest with Incense Ash, Mechanical Gear and Darkfire Charcoal. A lengthy stone stairway leads uphill from the plateau to a stone lantern, and farther on, two bandits and another Butcher occupy a campfire below the Cliff of Longing bell.

Plateau with stone stairs and a lantern at the top of the plank road above Red Serpent House in Phantom Blade Zero

The Butcher’s attacks and tells

He wields a hefty cleaver and a curved iron meat hook and links them in combos, and some strings go on for many hits. As with all enemies, a flash precedes each attack, and its color tells you how to respond. The game’s own loading tip sums it up: “Parry blue and dodge red. Keep this in mind and you’ll go far.”

TellWhat it meansYour answer
Blue flashParryable swingStance (Right Mouse)
Red flashCannot be blockedDodge (Shift)

His red-flash attack is a wide cleaver sweep that leaves a red arc trail around him. Don’t try to block it.

Red arc trail of the Butcher's red-flash cleaver sweep in Phantom Blade Zero

His codex entry, listed under “Butcher”, spells out the rest of his kit:

“Their iron hooks drag distant enemies within reach of their cleavers, while the filth they vomit forms a poisonous miasma around them. When they begin gorging on chunks of meat, they are restoring their strength for another murderous assault.”

In practice, that leaves you with three problems:

  • Backing off to range isn’t safe, because the hook pulls you back in.
  • Standing close slowly drains your health through the miasma, a small but steady loss.
  • Gorging on meat means he’s recovering, which gives you an opening.

How to beat the Butcher

On PC, the default bindings are Left Mouse for Light Attack, F for Sha-Chi Attack, Right Mouse for Stance (block and parry), and Shift for Dodge.

Lock onto him and stay within sword range. Don’t retreat to mid range, since his hook can pull you into cleaver range.
Tap Stance (Right Mouse) just before a blue-flash swing connects to parry it. This works against most of his attacks, so parries are the foundation of the fight.
Blue parry flash as Soul parries the Butcher's swing in Phantom Blade Zero
Dodge the red-flash cleaver sweep with Shift instead of blocking it. Expect to dodge far less often than you parry.
After parrying or dodging a swing, counter with a brief string of attacks, then raise your guard again. Parries deplete his Sha-Chi until his guard breaks, letting you finish with Sha-Chi Combos.
Soul hitting back at close range while the Butcher holds his hook and cleaver

Never start a long string the moment one of his combos ends. His next attack is often already winding up, and that timing is where the heaviest hit of the fight landed.

Heal when your health is around half. One heal was enough to finish the fight shown here.
Rush in and attack as soon as he starts gorging on meat. He’s recovering, so waiting only gives him his strength back.

Butcher difficulty: WAYFARER vs. PATHBREAKER

The fight shown here was won on WAYFARER, an easier difficulty than PATHBREAKER. Attempts on PATHBREAKER ended in death: his long combos stacked with the miasma drain burned through every heal. If he walls you there, switching to WAYFARER is a valid way past him (see the difficulty modes).


Butcher reward and how you know he’s down

The Butcher collapses when the health bar over his head runs out.

The Butcher collapsing after his health bar runs out in Phantom Blade Zero

The Remnant Dust counter in the top-right corner then shows “+ 360”, so the kill pays 360 Remnant Dust. No item dropped on this kill.

Remnant Dust counter showing plus 360 after the Butcher kill in Phantom Blade Zero